Skip to content
Monday, November 9, 2026
Elite Insight

The App's Most Eager Critics Are Shifting Film-Going Norms: I Couldn't Wait to Take Out My Phone'

I always power down my mobile device when I enter a cinema. Not only on vibrate – completely off. I state this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the specter of a classic director will appear to congratulate me. I consider it as a genuine little pleasures: for no less than an hour and a half, I become totally incommunicado. I keep my phone powered down during the scroll as well. It seems indulgent to stay put as other patrons slowly filter out, lit only by the closing titles.

And, more and more, by the illumination of the cataloguing app.

More than millions of users use Letterboxd, a cinema-tracking platform. Like the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a specific type of influencer who promotes latest films and finds joy in revisiting old classics. Users rate and review films, and the wittiest or most illuminating commentaries rise to prominence, incentivizing movie buffs to put in effort.

"Should I fail to articulate my impressions immediately when the film concludes, my reviews are far less coherent and articulate," said a student.

In a recent visit to the theater, the end titles had just begun before the man seated in front of me began typing his thoughts. Nearby, a pair sat, focused on their screens, noting their personal reactions.

The late artist David Lynch once offered advice: note every brilliant thought the precise instant it comes to mind. Otherwise, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "If you forget a good idea, you want to commit suicide." Lynch was addressing hopeful creators, this mindset pertains to the post-film ritual.

Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, without fail drafts his critiques from his theater seat.

"Should I fail to articulate my impressions immediately when the film concludes, my critiques are much less lucid and well-put," he explained. "The process demands a bit. I'm pretty slow, and my girlfriend isn't fond of it."

He goes to the movies often – 182 times in a single year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who at times have to ask him to leave so they can start tidying the theater. He thinks it acceptable to milk the credit sequence: "Upon buying a theater ticket, the credits are part of the film experience."

Letterboxd's most ardent supporters give credit to the platform with reinvigorating excitement around a challenged movie business, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also has the type of demographics brands desire – its largest segment of users is aged 18 and 24, then 25 to 35.)

Excitement begets further excitement; highly awaited movies witness a flurry of reviews on Letterboxd right after the initial screenings. The most-liked comment of an acclaimed adaptation – "Emily Brontë died in the 19th century yet this interpretation is still the worst thing that has ever happened to her" – has amassed in excess of 50,000 double-taps. A separate fictionalized retelling produced this juxtaposition to a pop star's documentary: "that other tour film discovered deceased."

"It's somewhat an addiction," remarked one user, a 33-year-old resident who has a career in marketing. He also chooses to jot down thoughts during the closing scroll. "Reflecting on what you just witnessed, right after you saw it, aids the artistic experience. It aids in understanding the key messages of a film. If it evokes a sense of a warm hug, that's not always something you recall five hours down the line."

Glidden feels most driven to critique a film if it was very good – or exceptionally bad. Case in point: he recently endured a sci-fi film. "I was actually so disappointed by how egregiously bad it was, that I was excited to take out my phone and assign it a half-star rating," he noted. (Glidden is a tougher critic than established reviewers, who awarded the film a more favorable review, labeling it "smart and entertaining stuff.")

A social media manager, a 28-year-old New Yorker who manages social media, viewed an acclaimed animated film at a cinema on the Upper West Side and remained to draft the review ("it got the highest rating"). He has clocked more egregious conduct: people taking out their phones to Letterboxd the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That action annoys me," he admitted.

One of the movie industry's most persistent urban legends recounts a exhibition of an early motion picture that depicted a train arriving at a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – as per this apocryphal anecdote – the footage of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera terrified the spectators so much that people fled in panic.

Many decades later, audience behavior can be just as problematic. Often, few people understand how to behave in a theater these days, especially when the theater darkens: viewers take pictures of the image, carry in smelly food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, sometimes participate in outright brawls.

Some individuals have taken to social media to discuss the propriety of writing reviews in the closing scroll. When one social media user

About the author

Robert Ward

A business strategist and innovation consultant with over 15 years of experience helping companies navigate digital transformation.

Elite Insight

Type to search articles.